Dying Is Not Death

Historically, there are certain constants and certain changes in human behavior. One of the constants is violence; people have always clobbered others.

But one change has significantly altered the modern world--the invention and introduction of the artifacts of technology, whether one looks at nuclear power or goes on down the list to cell phones and Pods. Each person must face this all-pervasive fact. Jacques Ellul even claims that technology is all-encompassing, all-powerful.

Indeed, violence is a constant; but not everyone is violent--some choose nonviolence, some are incapable of inflicting force on others. But there is another constant that all must experience: death. Each of us must die.

I’ve used death as an entry point into a sustained questioning of technology, specifically, the technology of the medical system. In a new book, Dying Is Not Death, I relate individual stories in eleven unconnected chapters. (The twelfth and final chapter is more theoretical.) Each chapter is written examining some aspect of dying and death from a more traditional humanistic point of view and, where applicable, from a Catholic perspective.

In a certain real sense, the book is a polemic. I strongly believe that technological artifacts have substantially changed our world: nature is no longer nature; humans are no longer humans. Because of technology a so-called human act often fails to meet the requirements of Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas. As believers, some of us must recognize what is happening and cry out!

Perhaps, with Jeff Dietrich, we must enter the realm of demonology. Perhaps we are confronting systemic structures that have betrayed a divine vocation. Perhaps we face the Devil!

Everyone wants power, its pleasures and signs. Everyone is tempted by the advantages of empire, either individual or nationalistic. Many carefully observe the stock market. Economics seems to reign supreme.

Perhaps the way of wisdom is to embrace the Cross. Perhaps a believer should strive to be powerless. Perhaps one must look for ways to live with technology and its artifacts. But how?

Moral teaching can be best presented through stories. Hence, one is often inspired by well done hagiography. Without any intention of writing about saints, I have portrayed persons and their approach to death in the book, Dying is Not Death. I’ve found that grace is always present. Some of the stories illustrate how one can avoid technological intrusions of the medical system as the end time approaches.

Lee Hoinacki

return to 4/07 CPF Newsletter